Manure and effluent present potential odour risks

 Ammonia 

bullet

Agriculture main source (90%) of ammonia emissions in UK

bullet

Current estimates (2006) are 315 x 103 t/year, of which 288 x 103 t/year from agriculture.

bullet

Most ammonia losses occur after spreading livestock waste, 30% of the national total

bullet

28% of national total is derived from livestock housing

bullet

Losses from grazing, 10% of national total, from storage 5% of national total

bullet

Remainder from nitrogen, fertilizer and crops

bullet

Approx. 50% of N deposited in atmosphere in the UK is as ammonia, the remainder is as oxides of nitrate from combustion, transport and industry

bullet

Trend is moving in the right direction although it has slowed in recent years. The emission target set for 2010 under the UNECE Gothenburg Protocol and EU target  is 297 x 103 t/year

 

Source: AEA Energy and Environment from Defra website              

Why is ammonia a problem ?

bullet

Soil acidification

bullet

Nutrient enrichment (eutrophication) of non agricultural soils and water

bullet

Ammonia is very soluble in water so readily deposited in rainfall (see above diagram)

bullet

Loss of valuable farm nutrient resource

Ammonia release:

bullet

Urine of mammals contains urea, poultry excreta contains uric acid, both can both may be broken down to release ammonia to the atmosphere

bullet

Urea is hydrolyzed by the enzyme urease to ammonium carbonate, this disassociates rapidly in water to produce OH ions:  NH3+H2O = NH4++OH

bullet

At this pH ammonia is predominantly in NH3 (molecular) form, and will diffuse into the air as long as the air concentration is lower than in the aqueous solution (urine etc.) 

bullet

Uric acid is hydrolyzed first to urea, by bacterial enzymes, the produced urea then behaves as outlined above

bullet

If poultry excreta is kept dry (< 30% moisture), then bacterial activity is inhibited, hence uric acid hydrolysis is inhibited and ammonia production is halted

Reducing ammonia losses

Livestock:

bullet

Reduce N excreted by animals by matching dietary inputs to nutritional requirements (amino acid inputs in pigs and poultry are particularly high)

bullet

Most animal housing is naturally ventilated and it is not possible to remove ammonia from air as it leaves the building. Costs of fitting ammonia filter systems exceed the profit margins per animal place

Naturally ventilated livestock housing presents a pleasant environment for the animals but allow gasses directly into the atmosphere. The alternatives are both impractical and expensive

Storage:

bullet

50% of all animal excreta stored as solids (FYM)

bullet

No real successful method of reducing ammonia emissions

bullet

Slurry in above ground or underground tanks with cover reduce emissions by around 80% but risk of explosion etc.

bullet

Only 20% of cattle slurry and 40% of pig slurry in UK stored in tanks

bullet

Remainder stored in weeping wall or lagoons (open topped)

It is virtually impossible to keep animal wastes completely 'encased' and out of sight

Spreading:

bullet

Injection of ammonia directly into soil, minimizing contact with air, therefore reducing diffusion

bullet

50% of animal waste produced in UK  cannot be injected, (solid FYM)

bullet

Rapidly incorporating manure or slurry by ploughing directly after spreading:

 

        Source: Adapted from MAFF, Animal Manure Practice Survey (1997)                

 

bullet

20 - 40% of UK soils are too shallow or stony for injection

bullet

Injection will increase nutrient loss by other methods, i.e. leaching

Pause for thought.....State 2 other benefits of incorporating manures and slurries rapidly following spreading.

Other:

bullet

There is little scope for reducing ammonia diffusion from grazing

bullet

Ammonia losses from fertilizer spreading are significant (13% of total agricultural emissions) there are few methods of reducing them owing to:

bullet

Majority of N fertilizer used in the UK is ammonium nitrate and only 1-2% of the N is lost as ammonia

bullet

Ammonia loss from urea (10% of fertilizer N use) is much greater at c15% of N applied

bullet

Reducing ammonia losses, therefore requires replacement of urea with (more expensive) ammonium nitrate

For more information on Ammonia in the UK CLICK HERE

______________________________

Greenhouse Gasses

Principal Greenhouse gasses:

bullet

Carbon dioxide

bullet

Methane

bullet

Nitrous oxide

bullet

Chlorofluorocarbons (CFC's)

Agriculture cannot be held entirely responsible for greenhouse gas emissions

Agricultural contribution (taking CO2 as a base):

bullet

Nitrous oxide is 310 times, and methane is 21 times, more potent than carbon dioxide in terms of radiative forcing over a 100 year period

bullet

CFC's rarely used in agriculture, except in refrigeration, but widely used in food industry

bullet

UK agriculture produces 38% of total methane, 66% of nitrous oxide and 1% of carbon dioxide in UK

Methane:

bullet

Atmospheric methane is increasing at the rate of 30 - 40 Tg/year

bullet

Global emission of methane is estimated to be 540 Tg/year

bullet

Of this, 70 - 100 Tg/year from enteric fermentation from livestock and 35 Tg/year from animal wastes

Major contributions global methane levels are:

bullet

Biogenic sources, eg. peat bogs & tundra - 25%

bullet

Rice paddies - 20%

Left: 'bogland'.    Right: Rice paddy, both contribute to greenhouse gas emissions

 
bullet

Enteric fermentation (mainly ruminants) - 15 - 20%

bullet

Landfill & coalmines - 8 - 10%

bullet

In the UK agriculture produces  38% of all UK methane emissions (the majority of which is enteric fermentation) with landfill sites being the largest emitter at 40%

 

       

                Source: AEA Energy and Environment from Defra website.    

Reduction of methane output:

bullet

Very little can be done at present

bullet

Reduce number of cattle, therefore enteric fermentation

bullet

Improve cattle production efficiency

bullet

Above two factors already underway by default. i.e. milk quota's, BSE, loss of farm incomes etc. (weeks 1 & 2) 

bullet

Some research work into methane reducing feed additives, but at present require withdrawal times so cannot be used on dairy cattle

Nitrogen oxides:

bullet

Nitrous oxide (N2O) - contributes to global warming. It is emitted from the soil and emission increases with N inputs.  The majority of nitrous oxide emissions in the UK is directly from soil - 63%.

bullet

Nitric oxide (NO) - contributes to acid deposition in soil, and formation of ozone in lower atmosphere. Emitted from soil in proportion to N inputs

bullet

Nitrogen Dioxide (NO2) - very reactive, contributes to acid deposition, small amount emitted from soil, but most absorbed by crop canopy, soil generally ignored as a source of this gas

bullet

Others, e.g. (N2O5) - usually present in the air and for these purposes can be ignored

 

 

Source: AEA Energy and Environment from Defra website.        

 

 

Reducing nitrous oxide emissions:

bullet

Reduce mineral N content of the soil by:

bullet

Analysis of soil from previous crop, manure applications, and soil organic matter before deciding on fertilizer policy

bullet

Timing of N applications to when crop has highest uptake potential

bullet

Timing of incorporation of organic manure and crop residues to avoid incorporating when soils are poorly aerated

Carbon dioxide:

bullet

Agriculture only produces 1% of UK's total CO2 emissions

bullet

Road transport 22%

bullet

Residential homes 15%

bullet

Energy Industries 39%

Pause for thought..........In wetland areas is there a tradeoff between increased biodiversity and methane emissions?

______________________________

 Farm odours  (Statistics: 1987 - 1990)

Sources of farm odours:

bullet

Complaints of odour from agricultural sources compiled and summarized by Environmental Health Departments

bullet

Manure and slurry spreading - 44%

bullet

Livestock buildings - 25%

bullet

Manure and slurry stores - 21%

bullet

Pig farms highest number of complaints - 47%

bullet

Poultry units - 25%

bullet

Cattle - 22%

Dilution of farm odours:

bullet

Depends on strength and source of odour and prevailing wind direction

bullet

There are no definitive or statutory criteria linking the frequency and concentration of odours to the occurrence of a nuisance. Guidelines have been set for other countries and industries:

bullet

Suburban areas - for no more than 2% of hours should average odour concentration exceed 5 OU/m

bullet

Rural areas - for no more than 2% of hours should average odour concentration exceed 10  OU/m3

bullet

OU = Odour unit as measured by olfactomotry

Pause for thought......Should people who move from the town to the country, be expected to tolerate odours from livestock units, on the basis that the farm was there first?

Back to Farm Pollution and Waste